Home World No Scrubs: More ports declare ban on EGCS Discharges

No Scrubs: More ports declare ban on EGCS Discharges

Exhaust gas cleaning systems (EGCS) – more commonly referred to as scrubbers – are an accepted equivalent measure in complying with the IMO 2020 global sulphur cap. The use of scrubbers has split the shipping industry. Ports around the world are looking at the impact of scrubber use in their waters.

A number of ports and regions have already stated that they will not allow the discharge of washwater from scrubbers.

The table below summarises North’s understanding of the positions taken by ports that have or will prohibit the use of scrubbers, or have placed conditions on their use.

This information is to the best of our knowledge and is for guidance only. For up to date and definitive information, contact the local authorities or agents.
Country Port Open loop EGCS discharge allowed? Comments
Argentina All Yes – the prohibition is currently suspended Regulation No. 15/2020 of the Environment Protection Bureau, which came into force on 10 August 2020, prohibited the discharge of washwater from the exhaust gas cleaning systems (EGCS) of national or foreign-flagged vessels into Argentinean jurisdictional, sea or river waters.

Pandi Liquidadores S.R.L. advise that on 24 September 2020, Prefectura Naval Argentina issued Resolution DISFC-2020-22-APN-DPAM#PNA that suspended the enforcement of the above Resolution 15/2020.

IT&L Legal Consultants advise that this resolution took effect from 3 October 2020 and warn that this suspension is provisional, and the restrictions have not been permanently overturned.
Australia All Yes According to AMSA Marine Notice 05/2019, wash water testing should be conducted upon commissioning of the EGCS and repeated every twelve months, as a minimum, for a period of two years. Ships may be directed not to discharge wash-water from an EGCS in Australian waters if this data, or evidence that samples have been taken for analysis, cannot be provided to AMSA before arrival at the first Australian port.

Bahrain Bahrain No

• Open loop operation not allowed in port or at anchor
• Open loop operation is allowed in Bahraini territorial waters and exclusive economic zone (EEZ) as long as it can be proved that the discharge of washwater complies with MEPC.259(68) and there is no negative impact on marine ecosystems.

Belgium All No

• Belgian federal law states discharge only allowed in coastal and open seawaters when at least 3nm off coast
• Discharges must not imperil EU Water Framework Directive objectives.
• Flemish regional law also confirms discharge not allowed in ports or inland waters.

Bermuda All ports Yes The maximum allowed sulphur content in fuel for Controlled Plants is 2.0%. Ships equipped with Exhaust Gas Cleaning Systems (EGCS) shall seek the prior approval of the Environmental Authority before its use in Bermuda’s territorial waters. Wash-water and residue from the EGCS shall be not disposed of in Bermuda or discharged into Bermuda’s waters but shall be stored on board the ship until outside of Bermuda’s waters.

Brazil All (except Vale terminals) Yes Prior to 23 July 2020, advice received from local correspondents was “ based on existing provisions in national legislation, especially Law 9.966/00, the discharge of effluents generated by Scrubbers or Exhaust Gas Cleaning Systems (EGCS) is not allowed and the vessel, when in Brazilian waters, must operate with fuel within specifications (sulphur content up to 0.5% m/m)”.

However, correspondents Brazmar advised on 23 July 2020 that the Directorate of Ports and Coasts (DPC) / Navy have changed their previous guidance on the topic, and that the discharge of wash water from open loop and/or hybrid Exhaust Gas Cleaning Systems (EGCS) is allowed within Brazilian Jurisdictional Waters until the competent environmental authority has the opportunity to better assess the scenario.

This is under the assumption that the subject EGCS is approved by Class, has a plan for compliance of SOx emissions and is approved as per requirements of resolution MEPC.259 (68) of IMO.
Brazil Vale ports and terminals No Vale instruct arriving vessels that the discharge of EGCS washwater is not allowed while operating in its Brazilian ports and terminals.

Vale recommends that vessels should be changed over to compliant fuel before entering contiguous zone or coastal waters (24 nautical miles from coastline).

PR China Inland river Emission Control Areas (ECAs), Port areas within coastal ECAs and Bohai Sea – the sea area within lines connecting the junction point of shorelines of Dandong, Dalian and shorelines of Yantai, Weihai. No

China MSA guidance prohibits the discharge of water washings from open- loop scrubbers in certain areas. The prohibited areas are:
• Inland river Emission Control Areas (ECAs)
• Port areas within coastal ECAs
• Bohai Sea – the sea area within lines connecting the junction point of shorelines of Dandong, Dalian and shorelines of Yantai, Weihai.
• The guidelines also prohibit the incineration of the water washing residues from any type of exhaust gas scrubber. Ships are required to keep accurate records of the stowage and disposal of the washing washings.
• If a vessel is not able to store the washing water it is required to switch to low sulphur fuel (not exceeding 0.5%) prior to entering the above areas. The guidelines also state that under certain circumstances a vessel may apply for an exemption if it uses fuel that does not meet the MSA’s requirements.
• A copy of the MSA’s guidelines for ships operating within the ECAs, including enforcement details can be found here.

Egypt All ports and Suez Canal No Suez Canal:

• Suez Canal Authority has issued Circular 08/2019. Clarification on this circular is provided here
• The authority puts no conditions or restrictions on marine fuels until Egypt ratifies MARPOL Annex VI – as such, sulphur cap is not in force.
• Wash water from open-loop scrubbers is not permitted to be discharged during transit of the canal

Egyptian Ports:

Kalimbassieris Maritime Egypt advise that the discharge of open loop scrubber washwater is not permitted in Egyptian territorial waters

Estonia All Ports Restricted

https://veeteedeamet.ee/sites/default/files/content-editors/clarification_of_exhaust_gas_cleaning_system_egcs_operations_in_territorial_waters_and_ports_of_estonia.pdfCircular Number 4 (21.10.19) refers to paragraph 10.1.6.1 of MEPC 184(59) and the restrictions on discharging chemical EGCS wash water including enclosed ports and estuaries. Exceptions for discharge into the sea are made if the ship operator can demonstrate that the washing water meets international requirements, required PH levels and does not cause adverse effects on human health or the environment. Prior authorisation is always required to discharge into the port area.The water Act which entered into force on 01.10.2019 does not treat washing water discharges as a violation of pollutant discharge from ships, if in compliance with MARPOL.The use of closed-loop EGCS is permitted in the territorial waters and ports of Estonia, if it meets the relevant requirements and is certified, however discharging of the washing water is not permitted.

Germany Inland Waterways , canals and ports within inland waterways No

• EGCS discharge is not permitted according to the convention on the collection, deposit and reception of waste generated during navigation on the Rhine and other inland waterways (CDNI Convention) .Restrictions apply to all inland waterways intended for general traffic except for the German part of Lake Constance and the stretch of the Rhine upstream of Rheinfelden.https://www.cdni-iwt.org/presentation-of-cdni/?lang=en

Gibraltar Gibraltar No

• Closed loop scrubbers are permitted in Gibraltar waters, Hybrid scrubbers operating in closed loop mode are also permitted, and open loop scrubber are temporarily not permitted as a precautionary measure until the Gibraltar Government arrives at a definitive policy decision with regards to (solely) open loop scrubbers

Hong Kong All Hong Kong Yes

• A ban on EGCS wastewater is not listed, however Hong Kong regulation L.N 135 of 2018 states that an exemption from use of non-compliant fuel is granted if the authorities are satisfied with the abatement technology used to reduce sulphur dioxide emissions. More detail on this and the duration of exemption can be found by accessing the document via link below.https://www.elegislation.gov.hk/hk/2018/ln135!en

India Adani Ports No Adani Ports and Special Economic Zone Ltd has issued a circular advising that the discharge of washwater from open-loop scrubbers is prohibited.

The instruction, which can be read here includes:

• vessels fitted with hybrid type of scrubbers should switch over to closed loop mode of operations before entering port limit
• vessels fitted with closed loop can continue using the system and ensure that it is in good working order throughout stay of vessel in port.
• vessels will not be permitted to use the open loop system at Adani port and should change over to compliant fuel before entering the port.
• vessels calling Adani ports would be required to submit certification for compliance with the above.
• vessels may be subject to Port state control inspection for validation of necessary compliance.

above will come in to force 1 November 2020.
Ireland Dublin and Waterford No

• Refer to Port of Dublin’s NOTICE TO MARINERS No. 37 of 2018 Prohibition on the Discharge of Exhaust Gas Scrubber Wash Water http://www.dublinport.ie/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/37-2018-Prohibition-on-the-Discharge-of-Exhaust-Gas-Scrubber-Wash-Water.pdf
• Port of Waterford weblink http://www.portofwaterford.com/news/marine-notices-prohibition-on-the-discharge-of-exhaust-gas-scrubber-wash-wa

Latvia All Ports  Conflicting advice

• EUROPEAN COMMISSION REPORT (2016): Allowed – no restrictions, but national authorities are of the position that open-loop scrubber discharge should be prohibited in territorial waters and ports
• ABS Report (2018): Prohibited in port waters
• Correspondents Pandi Balt Ltd advised in August 2018 that washwater discharges currently allowed under regulations but likely to be prohibited in future

Lithuania All Ports Conflicting advice

• EUROPEAN COMMISSION REPORT (2016): Allowed – no restrictions (in accordance with IMO Washwater Guidelines MEPC 184(59)).
• ABS Report (2018): Prohibited in territorial waters and ports
• We understand Lithuanian authorities are studying whether EGCS wash water discharges have serious impacts on the marine environment or not. When results will be clear, conclusions will be provided.

Malaysia All Ports No

• Malaysia shipping notice MSN 07/2019 prohibits the use of open loop scrubbers within 12 nautical miles from land. Vessels calling at Malaysian ports must operate in closed loop mode or change over to compliant fuel before arrival.

Newzealand Yes  – but discouraged Maritime NZ issue ‘Guidance on the use of exhaust gas cleaning systems (scrubbers) for ports, regional authorities and ships’.

The guidance is non-statutory, but MNZ encourages the industry to implement the following measures until work currently underway in respect to the use of scrubbers has been completed.

They request that all ships carrying scrubbers and operating in New Zealand’s territorial waters engage with the relevant port and regional authorities, and as a precautionary measure that where possible they avoid discharging scrubber effluent close to shore by utilising alternate options such as:

• preparing for entry into New Zealand waters by carrying compliant low sulphur fuel in order to use this when operating in sensitive environments, as identified by the relevant regional authorities.
• operating closed loop scrubber functionality in zero discharge mode and retaining any effluent on board until able to dispose of at the next available port facility.
• discharging any open loop scrubber washwater outside territorial waters.

https://www.mfe.govt.nz/marine/guidance-use-of-exhaust-gas-cleaning-systems-scrubbers

Norway The World Heritage Fjords sea areas of Geirangerfjord and Nærøyfjord Restricted

• The World Heritage Fjords sea areas of Geirangerfjord and Nærøyfjord restrict the use of open loop scrubbers, but not closed loop.Section 14b of the relevant Norwegian Maritime Authority’s regulation can be accessed at the link below.https://www.sdir.no/en/shipping/legislation/directives/amendments-to-the-regulations-on-environmental-safety-for-ships-and-mobile-offshore-units/

Oman All No

• Open-loop scrubber discharge is not permitted in Oman territorial waters

Pakistan Port of Karachi and Port Bin Qasim No

• The Government of Pakistan Ministry of Maritime Affairs (Ports and Shipping) circular number 001/2020 prohibits the discharge of wash-water from open loop scrubbers. If closed loop scrubbers are not in use then compliant fuel should be used and changed over before arriving in port waters.

Panama Panama canal No

• NT NOTICE TO SHIPPING No. N-1-2020 “Vessel Requirements”, Section 31 states the following and can be accessed hereThe use of open loop scrubbers or hybrid scrubbers in open loop mode is prohibited in Panama Canal waters. Vessels opting to use closed loop scrubbers or hybrid scrubbers in closed/ zero discharge mode shall submit documents to the panama-canal authority as detailed in section 31 E.Additionally, Section 28 (5) of the same document states: “Residues from the Exhaust Gas Cleaning System (EGCS) wash-water are to be collected on board. Discharging these residues into the water bodies under the responsibility of the Panama Canal or incinerating them on board is not permitted.”

Portugal All Ports No

• Use of open loop scrubbers are not allowed from entry of the ship into the port, along the port channel and at berth (moored), until the ship leaves the port. Only closed loop operation is allowed.

Saudi Arabia All Ports No

• Saudi Port Authorities have now banned exhaust wash water discharges from open loop EGCS systems in Saudi ports until an environmental standard is issued in this regard.

Singapore Singapore No

• Ban on the use of open loop scrubbers expected to take effect on 1 January 2020

Spain Algeciras, Cartagena, Huelva No

• Use of open loop scrubbers is prohibited at the Spanish ports of Algeciras, Cartagena and Huelva. At present no other Spanish ports have imposed this ban.

Sweden Stockholm, Trelleborg and Petroport, Stenungsund No Whilst there is no nationwide ban in Swedish waters on the use of open loop scrubbers, some ports have placed local restrictions:

• Stockholm – North’s correspondents advise that there is an open loop scrubber ban in Stockholm
• Trelleborg – Chalmers University in Gothenburg advise of ban of open loop scrubbers in port of Trelleborg. See section 29 of the Swedish language version of the Trelleborg port regulations (https://www.trelleborgshamn.se/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/Hamnordning-G%C3%A4llande-fr%C3%A5n-1-januari-2020.pdf).

Petroport, Stenungsund – See section 12 of harbour regulations which state “Vessels calling at the Port are not allowed to use Open-loop System for scrubbers”. See http://www.petroport.se/wp-content/uploads/2019/11/PetroPort-Harbour-Regulations-2016_v8-nov-2019-1.pdf

United States Californian Ports and Waters No

• The Californian ARB OGV regulations stipulate only distillate fuels can be used to comply with the 0.1% sulphur limit
• Changeover to compliant distillate fuel (MGO or MDO) prior to entering Californian waters

United States Connecticut Ports and Waters No

• Discharge of exhaust gas scrubber washwater into Connecticut waters from any vessel is prohibited
• VGP 2013: 6.5.9 Discharge of exhaust gas scrubber washwater into Connecticut waters from any vessel covered under the VGP or sVGP is prohibited.
• This condition is necessary for compliance with CGS section 22a-427, Standards No.1, 2, 9, 12, 14, 15, and 24 of the CT WQS.

United States Hawaii Ports and Waters Yes – conditional

• Additional requirements under VGP 2013 Section 6.6.
• The State of Hawaii (Clean Water Branch) issued ‘Blanket Section 401’ Water Quality Criteria (WQC).
• This covers 27 categories of effluent discharge from an applicable vessel (EGCS washwater being one) that have received the best control or treatment into waters of the State of Hawaii incidental to the normal operation of the applicable vessels

United Arab Emirates Abu Dhabi Ports Yes – conditional

• Abu Dhabi Ports Company Policy:
• Sludge generated from exhaust gas scrubber washwater discharge must not be discharged into port waters.
• Exhaust gas scrubber washwater discharge may only be discharged in port waters if free from pollutants.
• Any exhaust gas scrubber sludge should be discharged from a vessel to an ADPC licensed waste disposal contractor http://www.adports.ae/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/20131003_Vessel-Discharge-Draft-C.pdf

United Arab Emirates Fujairah No

• Notice to Mariners No. 252 from Port Fujairah prohibits use of open loop scrubbers in its waters

Source: The North of England